Why you should not borrow to buy a car (2024)

Why you should not borrow to buy a car (1)

  • Report this article

John Ntende Why you should not borrow to buy a car (2)

John Ntende

Manager Corporate Planning at Electricity Regulatory Authority

Published Feb 5, 2024

+ Follow

I bought my first car (a blue Toyota Premio) back in 2010 at ugx 12m. The car is still in my possession and is now used as a delivery vehicle for our food condiments manufacturing business. The most expensive car I have driven cost me ugx 15m. I paid cash for these cars! I have never been one to be excited by cars which seems odd to many people because I can easily afford to drive relatively nicer cars.

One reason is that I am a trained accountant who is also keen on achieving financial independence as quickly as possible. I clearly know that a car (especially a personal car) is a bad investment. This is because cars rapidly depreciate and in accounting, we reduce their value each year. This is unlike other assets like land or shares which tend to appreciate with time.

So cars are not investments. Yes, they are necessities to move you around but they should not be considered good investments. The clothing you are wearing is essential but is not an investment.

To achieve financial independence we must acquire assets and reduce liabilities. So the idea of buying a car which is a bad investment using borrowed funds runs counter to the logic of trying to build wealth quickly.

Let me demonstrate. Suppose you acquire a black shiny Toyota Harrier (2010 model) for about ugx 60m and you use a five-year credit facility at say 22% interest rate per annum. Within five years you will have repaid a total of ugx 99.6m with a monthly repayment of ugx 1.66m. The total interest cost would have come to ugx 39.6m (this figure excludes all the loan fees including arrangement fees and insurance). In five years the value of your car will probably be less than ugx 30m. So in essence you have a driven a nice comfy car but it is a bad investment and you have lost money.

Recommended by LinkedIn

Would you pay $2bn for this car? Ricky Husaini 8 years ago
The Bear Case For Carvana Is Compelling Peter Cohan 4 years ago
Negative Equity, a Canadian Auto-Industry Epidemic Robert Varga 5 years ago

Now what if you had invested the ugx 60m in a simple Unit trust earning 11% per year? This investment would have grown to ugx 101.1m in five years. So you can clearly see that investing the cash in a real investment is better than buying the car.

Of course, some people will argue that cars are necessary and you can't really do without one. I would definitely agree with these people and suggest to them to buy more affordable and reliable second-hand cars. I would also encourage them to save slowly and acquire the cars using cash rather than using credit. Alternatively, they could raise at least 60% of the car value and borrow only 40%.

We can see the logic behind my argument, but we all know that most people don't make financial decisions logically. Most of us use emotion. We go to a car bond and fall in love with the prettiest car we can find which will make us look good among our peers, friends, and family. This traps us into buying cars we can't afford and taking on unnecessary debt.

However, achieving financial independence requires us to sacrifice and be modest with our money. This way we incur some emotional pain in the short run but smile all the way to the bank a few years down the road.

Like
Comment

20

7 Comments

Erina Jackie

Working

3mo

  • Report this comment

Thank you 🤝for sharing this! It helps alot

Like Reply

1Reaction

ATUHAIRE DARIAS

Electrical Engineering | G.M.U.I.P.E

3mo

  • Report this comment

Candid remarks here, thanks John Ntende !!!!

Like Reply

1Reaction

Huzaifah Kisegerwa

Telecommunications Engineer | Senior Internal Auditor.

3mo

  • Report this comment

I think the comparison of Borrowing to buy a car and investing in a unit trust isn't very fair and compares 2 different scenarios. Investment in the unit trust is on the assumption that one has 60MIllion in cash to invest. Which isn't the case for someone borrowing.If one borrowed 60Million at 22%, and invested the borrowed funds in a unit trust making up to 101 Million, thier gain after 5 years considering total principle and interest payment of 96 Million, would only be 6 Million.

Like Reply

1Reaction

Eunice Muwangala

Technology Service Delivery | Governance & Risk Enthusiast | Entrepreneur

3mo

  • Report this comment

This is spot on John. I couldn't agree more.I keep preaching this message to my peers in the hope that they will dare to think logically.

Like Reply

2Reactions 3Reactions

Abdunasser Kalyabulo

Sales team training|Learning and development | Training Manager | Sales team Management| Corporate Trainer| YET |Trainer of Trainers | Development | Customer Relationship Management | Instructional Design | Recruitment.

3mo

  • Report this comment

Tremendous way of looking at finances.

Like Reply

1Reaction 2Reactions

See more comments

To view or add a comment, sign in

More articles by this author

No more previous content

  • Why you should avoid envy May 18, 2024
  • Avoid lifestyle inflation May 17, 2024
  • Why you should track your net worth May 16, 2024
  • The Parable of the Talents May 15, 2024
  • past, present, future May 14, 2024
  • Navigating the Shadows: The Unspoken Realities of Entrepreneurship May 13, 2024
  • The wealth bucket 🪣 May 12, 2024
  • Assets vs liabilities May 11, 2024
  • TIPPING POINTS May 10, 2024
  • How to evaluate an investment idea? May 9, 2024

No more next content

See all

Sign in

Stay updated on your professional world

Sign in

By clicking Continue to join or sign in, you agree to LinkedIn’s User Agreement, Privacy Policy, and Cookie Policy.

New to LinkedIn? Join now

Insights from the community

  • Airline Management How can airlines choose the best financing option for their new aircraft?
  • Airline Management What are the risks and rewards of leasing a fleet of aircrafts?
  • Rolling Stock What are the benefits and drawbacks of leasing versus owning rolling stock assets?
  • Accounting How can you use relevant costs to evaluate lease or buy decisions?
  • Aviation How can aviation companies choose the right lease financing option for their aircraft leasing needs?
  • Aviation How can you value aircraft for leasing based on lessee type?
  • Cash Flow Analysis How do you deal with negative NPVs or zero NPVs?
  • Airline Management What are the most effective ways to manage aircraft leasing and financing?

Others also viewed

  • How to Remove Hypothecation from RC Himanshu kk 3y
  • Fiat Chrysler Automobiles confirms investment cuts for Alfa Romeo relaunch Luca Cosmai 8y
  • How Tesla Became Debt-Free in Just Two Decades EVANNEX Aftermarket Tesla Accessories 1y
  • A quiet Friday for London’s AIM, LeasePlan pulls dual IPO, Tencent postpones $1bn NY IPO raise, lithium supplier Livent down 5% in its NYSE IPO… Julian Bosdet 5y
  • Like Paying Cash - Take Seven Years! John Wilkinson 4y
  • GlobalData: UK Car Market Hugely Dependent Upon Motor Finance Ben MacGregor 7y
  • WLC - Whole Life Cost, What the hell does it mean? Jake Matthews 8y
  • THE 20/4/10 RULE FOR BUYING CARS ON LOAN Moses Musyoki 5y
  • When will the auto "boom" end? James Gillette 10y
  • Hertz: crashing out? Piers Grundy 4y

Explore topics

  • Sales
  • Marketing
  • Business Administration
  • HR Management
  • Content Management
  • Engineering
  • Soft Skills
  • See All
Why you should not borrow to buy a car (2024)

FAQs

Why you should not borrow to buy a car? ›

Cons of taking out an auto loan

Should you borrow to buy a car? ›

Even if you can afford to pay cash for the car, it may not be a smart financial move. You can improve your credit score and keep your savings intact with an auto loan, especially if you avoid borrowing more than you need.

Why you shouldn't let people borrow your car? ›

There can be legal implications, especially if your friend is involved in an accident and it's unclear who's at fault. You might be held liable, and lawsuits could follow.

What is the disadvantage of getting a loan for a used car? ›

Used cars can be a good fit if you're on a budget and they generally cost less to insure; however, interest rates for used car loans are often higher than for new car loans. A pre-qualification may make it easier to compare different loans and to negotiate rates and other features when you're finally ready to buy.

Is it bad to take a loan against your car? ›

The more equity you have in the loan, the lower your interest rate is likely to be. The biggest risk of using your car as collateral for an auto equity loan is that if you default on the loan, your bank or lender can take possession of your vehicle to help repay your debt. Fees might also apply.

Is it smart to use a personal loan to buy a car? ›

A personal loan can be a good idea to finance a used car if conventional financing isn't available or if you can't qualify for an auto loan. Rates can be higher and repayment terms shorter, compared to traditional auto loans. You may be able to avoid repossession of your vehicle if you default on a personal loan.

Is car loan debt good or bad? ›

Generally speaking, cars purchased with a large down payment and with a short-term car loan are considered to be good debt. That's because large down payments usually mean lower interest rates. Further, a shorter loan term means you'll pay less in interest over the life of the loan.

Why you should avoid car loan? ›

Your vehicle will depreciate the moment you drive off the lot. A car may lose 20 percent of its value in the first year. If you have a high interest rate, you could owe more than your car is worth — what's called being upside-down on your loan. Being upside-down on a car loan is a bad situation.

Why do owners give up their cars? ›

They want to help the environment. Some car donors will donate a car when they decide to use public transit or rideshare instead of owning a vehicle. Often when car owners decide to reduce their carbon footprint they will donate their gasoline powered vehicle in favor of public transportation.

Should I let my sister borrow my car? ›

As long as you give the person permission and they only drive the car occasionally, there shouldn't be an issue. Accidents, however, can happen anytime. Even a minor accident can cause confusion about whose insurance covers the damage. Find out what happens when you lend your car to a family member or friend.

Is a 72-month car loan bad? ›

Because of the high interest rates and risk of going upside down, most experts agree that a 72-month loan isn't an ideal choice. Experts recommend that borrowers take out a shorter loan. And for an optimal interest rate, a loan term fewer than 60 months is a better way to go. You can learn more about car loans here.

Is a 96 month car loan bad? ›

If you choose a 96-month car loan, then you'll end up paying significantly more overall due to the higher interest rates. You also get fewer options, as 96-month car loans aren't as popular as 72-month loans. This could be an issue if you have your heart set on a certain vehicle.

What is a good interest rate for a car for 72 months? ›

What is a good interest rate for a 72-month car loan? An interest rate under 5% is a great rate for a 72-month auto loan.

What are the risks of letting someone borrow your car? ›

As per the California Vehicle Code Section 17150, every car owner is liable for injury, death, or property damages due to the vehicle's operation by any person who has been using it with expressed or implied permission of the owner.

Are auto loans risky? ›

Credit Risk

It's also a credit risk to have car loans. Within a 5-year span, it's very likely that you're going to have at least one major financial emergency.

Does a car loan affect your credit score? ›

Each time you submit an application for a credit product, the lender you've applied with will conduct a credit check on you. Each time a lender does this, it will leave what is known as a 'hard inquiry' on your report, which can impact your credit score.

Is it better to finance a car through your bank? ›

The bank may even offer incentives to financing with them if you do all your banking under their roof. When financing a car through a bank, you have the advantage of shopping around at various institutions in order to get a competitive deal or terms that best align with your budget and credit profile.

What should you not use a loan to purchase? ›

In addition, you shouldn't use loan proceeds for purchases that will violate your loan terms, which may include gambling, tuition, a house down payment, or anything illegal.

Why do dealerships want you to finance through them? ›

For example, auto dealers earn additional profits when they finance your loan through specific lenders they work with. They may even receive incentives to send the loans through their financing partners.

What are the negative consequences of taking on debt? ›

People with debt are more likely to face common mental health issues, such as prolonged stress, depression, and anxiety. Debt can affect your physical well-being, too. This is especially true if the stigma of debt is keeping you from asking for help.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Aracelis Kilback

Last Updated:

Views: 5807

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (44 voted)

Reviews: 83% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Aracelis Kilback

Birthday: 1994-11-22

Address: Apt. 895 30151 Green Plain, Lake Mariela, RI 98141

Phone: +5992291857476

Job: Legal Officer

Hobby: LARPing, role-playing games, Slacklining, Reading, Inline skating, Brazilian jiu-jitsu, Dance

Introduction: My name is Aracelis Kilback, I am a nice, gentle, agreeable, joyous, attractive, combative, gifted person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.